SEC Proposes to Eliminate Shareholder Proposal Rule and Reform the Proxy Solicitation Process

On September 16, the SEC proposed three major changes to the proxy regime for US public companies:

Elimination of requirement to include shareholder proposals. The SEC proposed rescinding Exchange Act Rule 14a-8, the proxy rule that has long required US public companies to include shareholder proposals in their proxy materials. This federal regime has generated considerable controversy in part because of its use by activists – including those with minor ownership stakes –seeking to advance political and social agendas.

Expanded discretionary voting authority. Companies would no longer be prohibited from exercising discretionary voting authority (i.e., the power to vote on behalf of a shareholder with respect to a matter that is not included on the proxy card) with respect to timely-received shareholder proposals that are presented at a meeting but not included in the company’s proxy materials.

Modernizing the proxy solicitation process. In a separate proposing release, the SEC proposed additional updates to the proxy rules to modernize the proxy solicitation process to reflect developments in market practice and technology.

Together, these proposals represent a significant overhaul of the federal proxy rules, and have the potential to fundamentally alter the timing, cadence and compliance obligations that US public companies face in connection with shareholder meetings. They are, however, unlikely to become final before the 2027 proxy season.

Key points to note about the proposals:

Rescission of Rule 14a-8

Applies to all companies required to file proxies. Rule 14a-8 would be rescinded for all public companies subject to the proxy rules, including registered investment companies and business development companies.

Rule 14a-8 exceeds the SEC’s statutory authority. To justify rescission of Rule 14a-8, the SEC unambiguously stated that the rule exceeds the Commission’s statutory authority under Exchange Act Section 14(a). The SEC emphasized that it has no authority to determine which matters are a proper subject for a shareholder vote, including shareholder proposals. In addition, the SEC described several independent policy reasons to rescind the rule.

Managing the 2027 proxy season. As noted above, we do not expect the rescission of Rule 14a-8 to take effect before the 2027 proxy season. We accordingly expect that, during the 2027 proxy season, companies will continue to follow the current rules and procedures regarding shareholder proposals, including the submission of notices to the SEC as required by Rule 14a-8(j) when they intend to exclude proposals under Rule 14a-8.

Looking ahead. If Rule 14a-8 were to be rescinded, state law or a company’s governing documents would determine whether a shareholder proposal must be included in a company’s proxy materials. However, state law generally does not require companies to include shareholder proposals in company proxy materials or provide any substitute for Rule 14a-8. As a result, the current shareholder proposal system would cease to exist unless state law or individual companies provide replacement frameworks. We accordingly may see state-level efforts to develop statutory or regulatory frameworks for shareholder proposals, particularly where current state law requirements are unclear on shareholder proposals. Interested parties may also urge companies to consider bylaw changes to facilitate privately ordered shareholder proposal frameworks.

Amendments to Discretionary Authority Rule – Rule 14a-4(c)

Expanded discretionary proxy voting authority for companies. Companies would no longer be prohibited from exercising discretionary voting authority (i.e., the power to vote on behalf of a shareholder with respect to a matter that is not included on the proxy card) with respect to timely-received shareholder proposals that are presented at a meeting but not included in the company’s proxy materials. In several recent cases where shareholders have conducted their own proxy solicitation for a proposal by filing and delivering their own proxy materials (an approach that became more viable after the SEC adopted the “universal proxy” rules), companies felt compelled to include the shareholder proposal on their proxy cards so that they could vote shares represented by proxies on the proposal, even though the proxy rules did not require that they do so. The expansion of discretionary authority would allow a company to vote shareholders’ shares on a proposal that is not included in the company’s proxy materials, provided that the company includes a brief description of the proposal and how it intends to vote.

New opt-out right for shareholders. To balance the expanded discretionary voting authority, companies would be required to include a check box on their proxy cards that, if checked by a shareholder, would prevent the company from exercising discretionary voting authority with respect to that shareholder’s shares on proposals not included on its proxy card.

Modernization of Proxy Solicitation Rules

Elimination of annual report delivery requirement. Companies that have a Form 10-K already on file would no longer have the obligation to deliver a separate annual report to security holders, such as a “glossy” annual report or a “Form 10-K wrap,” although companies would be able to choose to send an annual report voluntarily. The requirement to provide a stock performance graph would also be eliminated for all companies other than investment companies, as well as any other disclosure that goes beyond what is required in Form 10-K or is available in other SEC filings.

Elimination of 20-business-day waiting period when incorporating by reference. The proposal would remove the requirement in Schedule 14A and Forms S-4 and F-4 to send a proxy statement or prospectus at least 20 business days before a shareholder meeting when the document incorporates information by reference. This would give companies greater flexibility in planning shareholder meetings, particularly meetings relating to business combination transactions.

Elimination of notices of exempt solicitations. The proposal would eliminate Exchange Act Rule 14a-6(g), which currently requires any shareholder owning more than $5 million of a company’s securities to submit a Notice of Exempt Solicitation on EDGAR whenever that shareholder conducts a written solicitation under the exemption available to persons who are not seeking the authority to vote other shareholders’ proxies. These notices have been used by shareholders to publicize their claims on a company’s EDGAR page. Shareholders would no longer be able to use a company’s EDGAR page as a platform to broadcast their exempt solicitations.

Minimum broker search period shortened from 20 to five business days. Currently, companies must initiate the broker search process, i.e., the inquiry to banks, brokers, and other nominees record holders to find out how many copies of proxy materials are needed for beneficial owners holding shares in “street name,” 20 business days before the record date. Considering the technological advancements that make it possible to conduct the search significantly faster and the SEC Staff’s recent statement that it would not object to a shorter period, the minimum broker search period would be reduced to five business days. The procedural and timing requirements for coordinating delivery through intermediaries generally would remain unchanged. A shorter broker search period would help reduce delays in holding meetings or completing transactions and narrow the window for activists and hostile bidders to learn of a record date, acquire shares, and gain an early advantage in a campaign.

Proxy statement cover pages to require contact information. The cover pages of Schedule 14A and Schedule 14C would require contact information for a representative who can respond to questions or comments regarding the filing.

Comments on these proposals are due by November 20, 2026.

You May Also Be Interested In